
Kelly's 1985 Dodge Charger was returned to the NTV parking lot after realizing her car tire was flat - this was due to the tire having been slashed. Michael Biby was charged for the slashed tire, but seems to have had no other ties to Kelly's disappearance.

Within the car were Kelly's personal belongings, including her purse, but the car keys were missing. However, a family member claims that Kelly's keys were found in the front yard of her home a few days after her disappearance.

Kelly's final clothing and accessories description is: A dark purple rugby shirt with a red, gold and white insignia and a white collar and cuffs, stonewashed cut-off blue jean shorts with strings hanging, brown suede loafers, a gold domed ring, a gold and emerald ring, a gold bracelet, a gold watch, triangular earrings and a gold and diamond ring with an inset Mexican coin showing the image of an eagle.